Before I started reading this novel by Elizabeth Acevedo, I looked at the cover and saw the word "poet." I thought to myself "this will be a challenge." I am not a huge fan of poetry and this is 375 pages full of it. A whole novel. To say the least, I was skeptical. Whenever I think of poetry, I always think of it as something I will find difficult to read and something that will most likely not benefit me to read. I know it's harsh, but that was my experience from high school and even prior to high school. To my surprise, this novel proved me wrong.
As I was reading, I found myself enjoying how fast it was to read, how easy it was to follow, and how the content pulled me in. This novel is about a teenage girl who is experiencing new thoughts, feelings, and ideas all while under the strict control of her Catholic parents. She is always torn. She is always deciding with three factors in mind-- her feelings, her mom's feelings, and God's feelings. She feels immense pressure to act a certain way in her community and is forced to conceal who she really is. This is a daily struggle for her. I wondered how long she could take this piling pressure before she would rebel or hide any trace of who she really is just to appease the people surrounding her. While I was reading, I thought about how many people are in the same position as her. So many people struggle with issues like this and many could find solace in finding out that someone else is going through a hardship just like them.
While I was reading, I found a poem that I think a lot of people can relate to. In this poem, called "On Papi," she describes her father's role that he plays in her life. The best way to sum up the poem and her relationship with her father is in the final line. It states, "Just because your father's present doesn't mean he isn't absent" (p.65). When I read this, I thought about how many kids, even adults too, could relate to this line. She feels like her dad is there in her physical life, but always vacant in her emotional life. He is there in their home every day, but he could be a stranger and she would not know the difference. This makes me very sad. It seems like we live in a world now where it is rare that a father is involved in his child's life. I always think about this when I hear children talk about their parents and how they are not around and how I want to do something, anything, to make them feel better.
My Blog List
Monday, February 18, 2019
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
Before I started reading this novel by Elizabeth Acevedo, I looked at the cover and saw the word "poet." I thought to mysel...
-
As I was reading my second Katie Kazzoo Switcheroo book for the 20 book challenge, I realized how many comprehension strategies and ...
-
When I was rereading this book, I noticed that there is a trend with the books I have chosen. They involve animals. The subject of an...

Hi Abby,
ReplyDeleteFirst I want to say good job getting through poetry! I also have trouble reading it so I never pick it up. I'm glad you have enjoyed it so far! I think we can all relate to this girl in that we can feel torn between who we really are and who people want us to be. It sounds like this book would be great for older students who may feel the same way.
I love the quote you found. It makes me wonder about her relationship with her father. If he's there with her everyday, what happens between them? I would hope that a lot of students without a parent could see that quote and feel less alone.
Hi Abby,
ReplyDeleteI completely understand where you are coming from with the poetry reading. The book I just read was precisely like that. I was really questioning the book, and wondering how I was going to make myself sit down to read. I am not a fan of poetry, I find it very hard to follow! Like you, I was amazed by how fast it went, along with how it captured me from the start. The quote you mention from the book is just amazing! I can completely relate to what she is saying. You are correct, it is unfortunate knowing that there are people out there that look at any of their parents and wonder, "do they even know who I am?". I feel like I could really relate to this book, and that I am looking forward to reading it soon! Ps. I can not believe those words just came out of my mouth!! :)